Link function selection in stochastic multicriteria decision making models

Link function selection in stochastic multicriteria decision making models

0.00 Avg rating0 Votes
Article ID: iaor20084052
Country: Netherlands
Volume: 172
Issue: 1
Start Page Number: 86
End Page Number: 100
Publication Date: Jul 2006
Journal: European Journal of Operational Research
Authors:
Keywords: simulation, statistics: multivariate, analytic hierarchy process
Abstract:

A stochastic formulation of the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) using an approach based on Bayesian categorical data models has been developed. However, in categorical data models it is known that the selection of the link function may have an impact on the model estimates. In particular, the selection of the probit link implies an assumption that model error terms are normally distributed and this normality assumption is regularly utilized in other related methods such as the multiplicative AHP. We examine model performance with respect to the choice of two model link functions. With regard to point estimates, it is found that the logit formulation is better able to replicate the estimates obtained by the eigenvector decomposition associated with the original formulation of the AHP. By contrast, the probit link produces priorities which are consistently more moderate than those of the AHP. The results suggest that the logit formulation will be preferred by decision makers who wish to replicate the AHP priorities as closely as possible. The results also suggest that the unexamined use of the normality assumption in other stochastic AHP methods may have an impact on priority estimates and thus is worthy of further attention.

Reviews

Required fields are marked *. Your email address will not be published.