Bounds on the competence of a homogeneous jury

Bounds on the competence of a homogeneous jury

0.00 Avg rating0 Votes
Article ID: iaor201111722
Volume: 72
Issue: 1
Start Page Number: 89
End Page Number: 112
Publication Date: Jan 2012
Journal: Theory and Decision
Authors: ,
Keywords: stochastic processes
Abstract:

In a homogeneous jury, the votes are exchangeable correlated Bernoulli random variables. We derive the bounds on a homogeneous jury’s competence as the minimum and maximum probability of the jury being correct, which arise due to unknown correlations among the votes. The lower bound delineates the downside risk associated with entrusting decisions to the jury. In large and not‐too‐competent juries the lower bound may fall below the success probability of a fair coin flip–one half, while the upper bound may not reach a certainty. We also derive the bounds on the voting power of an individual juror as the minimum and maximum probability of her/his casting a decisive vote. The maximum is less than one, while the minimum of zero can be attained for infinitely many combinations of distribution moments.

Reviews

Required fields are marked *. Your email address will not be published.