Article ID: | iaor1992410 |
Country: | Netherlands |
Volume: | 46 |
Issue: | 2 |
Start Page Number: | 143 |
End Page Number: | 161 |
Publication Date: | May 1990 |
Journal: | European Journal of Operational Research |
Authors: | Pinsonneault Alain, Kraemer Kenneth L. |
Keywords: | artificial intelligence: decision support |
In this paper the authors analyze the empirical research on the impacts of electronic meetings on group processes and outcomes. They define and differentiate two broad types of electronic meeting systems: Group Decision Support Systems (GDSS) and Group Communication Support Systems (GCSS). The authors then present a framework and method for analyzing the impacts of such information systems on groups that they develop from the literature of organization behavior and group psychology. The authors review the empirical research and findings concerned with the impacts of GDSS and GCSS on groups, and they compare and contrast these findings. Finally, the authors conclude by discussing the implications of the present analysis on the focus of attention and the design of future research. The review of the empirical research suggests that GDSS and GCSS have similar impacts on some aspects of group processes and outcomes, but opposite impacts on other aspects. GDSS and GCSS both increase the depth of analysis of groups, increase participation, decrease domination by a few members, and increase decision quality. On the other hand, GDSS increase consensus reaching, decrease decision time, increase confidence in the decision by the group members, increase the satisfaction of group members with the process, and increase the satisfaction of the group members with the decision. GCSS decrease cooperation, increase the time to reach a decision, and decrease the confidence in decisions.