Let (X,Y,Z) be a triple of payoff processes defining a Dynkin game &Rtilde;(σ,τ)=E[Xσ1{τ>σ}+Yτ1{τ<σ}+Zτ1{τ=σ}], where σ and τ are stopping times valued in [0, T]. In the case Z = Y, it is well known that the condition X ≤ Y is needed in order to establish the existence of value for the game, i.e., infτ supσ &Rtilde;(σ, τ) = supσ infτ &Rtilde;(σ, τ). In order to remove the condition X ≤ Y, we introduce an extension of the Dynkin game by allowing for an extended set of strategies, namely, the set of mixed strategies. The main result of the paper is that the extended Dynkin game has a value when Z ≤ Y, and the processes X and Y are restricted to be semimartingales continuous at the terminal time T.